Some thoughts on Tom Finney, and on how Bangu lost out to the force of Flamengo

The legacy of the late Tom Finney is not mirrored in Brazil - Action Images
Last Saturday I gave a lecture in Rio where I was honoured with the presence of Juninho Pernambucano in my small audience.

I prepared my material the day before, and in an aside about the historical depth of English football, I sought to make a few points by using the example of Tom Finney.  Poignancy was added when the news came through that Finney had died at the age of 91 – certainly one of the candidates for the title of England’s best ever footballer.

 

I knew, though, that even a student of the game as diligent as Juninho would not have heard of Finney.  Although the great man had played in Brazil in the 1950 World Cup, it was not a moment on which Finney could look back with much pride.  And why should a Brazilian born in 1975 have heard of a player from previous decades who spent his entire career with Preston North End?

This neatly brings us to a point I was trying to make in my lecture.  If English football is currently so successful, and is held up all around the world as a reference, then part of that is explained by a simple equation.  The new money entering the game has proved so effective because the old culture is so strong.  And some of this can be explained by the example of Finney.

He played at a time when top footballers in England were deplorably treated.  With no freedom of contract, they were bound to their club for as long as the latter desired.  And the maximum wage was still in operation, meaning that even an artist like Finney, capable of filling stadiums up and down the country, could earn little more than a skilled factory worker.

Palermo came in with an offer that would have made Finney a wealthy man.  He was not even told about it.  Preston were not selling, and that was that!  And there would have been little point, in financial terms, in making the short move to Manchester United.  With the maximum wage restriction, he would not be able to earn at Old Trafford any more than he was getting at Preston.  And so, during the close season, he continued to work as a plummer.  And he played all of his club football for a team from a town so small that the entire population could fit into the old pre-modernisation Maracana stadium.

This is clearly absurd.  Yet it is also undeniable that something positive came from these grossly unfair restrictions on the players’ mobility and earnings potential.  By such measures, the process of concentration – where all the top players drift towards the biggest clubs – was retarded.  Not every club could boast a Tom Finney, but all of them, at some time, had players of great talent around whom the club could build a tradition and an identity.  All of this filters through to the current day, when clubs from all over England, with far more tradition than hopes of contemporary success, continue to draw crowds that are the envy of the Brazilian game.

Juninho acknowledged the point.  The division typically made in Brazil between big clubs (with mass support) and small ones (with next to no fans) was not one that could be easily applied to European football, especially in England.

Like much of the rest of South America, Brazilian football has had to fight against a centralisation which its roots in economic history.  Being an exporter of raw materials created strong ports and a weak hinterland – and thus most of the continent’s big teams are clustered in those bustling ports or nearby trade centres.

But even inside some of those big cities, the process of football centralisation is striking.  Take the example of Bangu, from Rio’s working class North Zone.  They have a long and proud tradition.  Some great players have worn their red and white stripes, such as legendary centre back Domingos da Guia and Zizinho, the idol of the young Pele.  They have a huge catchment area, and yet, no longer a national force, they survive on tiny gates towards the wrong end of the table in the Rio State Championship.  One of the Carnaval samba schools with the biggest following is Mocidade from the neighbouring district of Padre Miguel.  If Mocidade can agglomerate a mass support from Rio’s North Zone, then surely Bangu should be able to do something similar.  Put a club with the tradition of Bangu in the context of London or Buenos Aires and they would be huge.  But not in Brazil.  Why?

Radio has something to do with it.  Football in England pre-dates the electronic media, giving the sport a chance to grow locally and organically.  In Brazil, radio did much to spread the game – and as radio came into the peak of its power in the late 30s and 1940s, there was one club with whom it was very hard for the likes of Bangu to compete – Flamengo.

Between 1933 and 38 Flamengo had a visionary for a president.  Jose Bastos Padilha saw and understood the changes that were taking place in Brazilian football and society.  Professionalism came in, rocking the game’s amateur ethos.  Meanwhile, the relatively benign tropical fascism of Getulio Vargas sought to set up a cross-class alliance, forming a country where for the first time the black Brazilian was included in the national identity.

Flamengo responded by signing the leading black players of the day, including the son of Bangu, Domingos da Guia.  Even more important was charismatic, controversial and magnificently talented centre forward Leonidas da Silva.  At a stroke Flamengo rebranded themselves; they had been a club of the South Zone elite.  Now, dramatically, they had acquired the popular touch.  The clubs from the working class suburbs could not compete.

After a decade with Flamengo, the great Zizinho played some of his most mature football in a seven year spell in the red and white of Bangu.  He is a contemporary of Tom Finney, and there are similarities in their styles.  But even if Bangu had possessed an entire team of Finneys and Zizinhos it is hard to see how they could have avoided having their support base eaten up by Flamengo.  The local fan did not just want to associate himself with his own neighbourhood.  When he opted for Flamengo it was as if he was buying a stake in the new Brazil, the land of the future.

 





Latest articles

Brazilian Football Confederation confirm new goalkeeper coach and assistant manager

Flamengo reappoint Vanderlei Luxemburgo as Head Coach following Ney Franco sacking

Barcelona midfielder Rafinha delighted Xavi is staying with the club

Santos Vice-President Odílio Rodrigues Filho admits Robinho deal will be "a difficult operation"

Napoli goalkeeper Rafael Cabral hoping for Seleção return under Dunga

Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa discusses why he hasn’t returned to Ukraine

Report: Werder Bremen set to sign Internacional defender Cláudio Winck

Brazil to be less reliant on Neymar under new head coach Dunga?

New Brazil head coach Dunga looking to get fans behind national team again

Alexandre Pato’s agent admits he hasn’t had any contact from Internazionale

Cruzeiro rule themselves out of the running for Robinho’s signature

President Enrique Cerezo believes Atlético de Madrid can cope with Diego Costa and Filipe Luís sales and refutes Miranda rumours

Ex-Flamengo president recalls when the club were in a similar situation a decade ago

Palmeiras defender Juninho linked with Fluminense move

Atletico Mineiro set to face Lanus in Recopa Sudamerica decider this evening

Alexandre Gallo steps into Brazil U-23 Olympic role

Fabregas can't wait to join forces with Diego Costa at Chelsea this season

Shakhtar Donetsk chief pledges top security for club's Brazilian stars

Latest News.

  • All
  • Seleção
  • Teams
  • Players
July 23, 2014
21:29Brazilian Football Confederation confirm new goalkeeper coach and assistant manager
21:19Flamengo reappoint Vanderlei Luxemburgo as Head Coach following Ney Franco sacking
20:28Barcelona midfielder Rafinha delighted Xavi is staying with the club
19:42Santos Vice-President Odílio Rodrigues Filho admits Robinho deal will be "a difficult operation"
17:02Napoli goalkeeper Rafael Cabral hoping for Seleção return under Dunga
15:47Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa discusses why he hasn’t returned to Ukraine
15:17Report: Werder Bremen set to sign Internacional defender Cláudio Winck
14:59Brazil to be less reliant on Neymar under new head coach Dunga?
14:27New Brazil head coach Dunga looking to get fans behind national team again
14:05Alexandre Pato’s agent admits he hasn’t had any contact from Internazionale
13:46Cruzeiro rule themselves out of the running for Robinho’s signature
13:43President Enrique Cerezo believes Atlético de Madrid can cope with Diego Costa and Filipe Luís sales and refutes Miranda rumours
12:09Ex-Flamengo president recalls when the club were in a similar situation a decade ago
11:50Palmeiras defender Juninho linked with Fluminense move
11:25Atletico Mineiro set to face Lanus in Recopa Sudamerica decider this evening
11:12Alexandre Gallo steps into Brazil U-23 Olympic role
10:58Fabregas can't wait to join forces with Diego Costa at Chelsea this season
10:49Shakhtar Donetsk chief pledges top security for club's Brazilian stars
10:34New Technical Director Rinaldi has close relationship with Dunga
10:30Tim Vickery Column: Brazil may want to look further afield in order to regain reputation
10:07Report: Roma in negotiations with São Paulo to re-sign defender Rafael Tolói
July 22, 2014
23:27Report: Cruzeiro set to hold talks with Milan over Robinho
23:16Former Internacional forward Ignacio Scocco set for Newell's Old Boys return
23:11Agent confirms Robinho offers amid interest from Cruzeiro and Orlando City
20:43Dunga: I'm here to rescue Brazil
19:57Orlando City club president: Robinho would be great alongside Kaká
19:41Robinho: "For fans of Milan I can only say thank you for everything"
19:28Former Arsenal defender André Santos released by Flamengo after being attacked by his own fans
19:17Dunga named as new Brazil coach
14:36Al-Wasl team manager Majed Obaidallah confirms loan signing of Fábio Lima from Atlético Goianiense
13:47New Chelsea signing Filipe Luís confident he will fit in perfectly at Stamford Bridge
13:31Filipe Luís looking forward to working with Chelsea manager José Mourinho
13:25Kaka nearing Sao Paulo debut
13:15Former Brazil U-20 coach Lourenco claims he and Dunga never spoke in the past
12:44Report: Juventus and Roma could move for Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa following refusal to return to Ukraine
12:25Flamengo to keep hold of Ney Franco as manager- for now
12:251994 World Cup winner Jorginho set to be Brazil assistant manager again
12:14Former Palmeiras midfielder Valdivia has not moved to the Middle East for money
12:04Manchester United's Anderson criticised by ex-international Tostao
12:03Brazil set to name Luiz Felipe Scolari’s replacement this afternoon
11:44Former Brazil national team forward Adriano set for another comeback?
July 21, 2014
23:53Report: Barcelona to target São Paulo defender Rodrigo Caio
23:47La Liga newcomers Córdoba confirm the loan signing of forward Ryder Matos from Fiorentina
23:45Robinho taking his time over his next move
23:42Serie B newcomers Perugia sign veteran midfielder Rodrigo Taddei on a free transfer from Roma
23:352014 Brasileirão Round 11 summary: Internacional thump struggling Flamengo
23:25Palmeiras forward Henrique disappointed with his miss versus Cruzeiro
23:10Former Arsenal defender André Santos describes attack by Flamengo fans
23:04Deivid hailed by Atlético Paranaense head coach Doriva following Criciuma victory
22:30Atlético Paranaense head coach Doriva praises supporters and forwards
July 23, 2014
17:02Napoli goalkeeper Rafael Cabral hoping for Seleção return under Dunga
July 19, 2014
23:19Gerard Houllier explains why Lionel Messi was awarded the Golden Ball
23:13Neymar believes Brazil can learn from Germany and Spain
23:07Italian referee Nicola Rizzoli welcomes introduction of vanishing spray into Serie A after World Cup success
July 14, 2014
23:57FIFA President Sepp Blatter denies involvement in selection of Lionel Messi as Golden Ball winner
23:48FIFA Secretary-General Jérôme Valcke expects Russia and Qatar World Cups to match Brazil
23:13Maicon philosophical over Brazil World Cup disappointment
July 13, 2014
23:44Fred hopes Fluminense will give him time off after World Cup disappointment
23:41Fred confirms he has retired from international football
09:54Sambafoot Sunday: Brazil's 2014 World Cup Fallout: New Failures
July 12, 2014
23:51Joachim Low: Germany can be the first European nation to win in Latin America
23:48Dunga: Germany played as a unit
23:44Thiago Silva left frustrated by Netherlands defeat
23:35Oscar has "horrible feeling" after Netherlands defeat
July 11, 2014
22:50Germany forward Thomas Muller looking forward to playing in the Maracana
July 09, 2014
23:55Neymar agent Wagner Ribeiro makes astonishing attack of Luiz Felipe Scolari
23:51Brazil Head Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari insists Germany defeat "not all bad"
23:48Cafu refused entry to Brazil dressing room after Germany defeat
15:30Tim Vickery Column: A look at Brazil’s capitulation against Germany and what now for Luiz Felipe Scolari
July 08, 2014
23:59Luiz Felipe Scolari: “Who is responsible for this result? I am, it’s me”
23:55Germany forward Miroslav Klose "truly happy" to break Ronaldo's World Cup scoring record
23:50Julio Cesar struggles to comprehend Brazil defeat
23:39Brazil 1-7 Germany: Ruthless Germany tear Seleção apart to secure historic semi-final victory
23:29Brazil 1-7 Germany: Player ratings
20:10Brazil v Germany: line-ups
July 07, 2014
22:25Brazil legend Amarildo believes Neymar absence could work to the Selecao's advantage against Germany
22:22Germany Head Coach Joachim Low wary of "robust" Brazil
22:05Maicon disappointed with refereeing on Neymar challenge
July 06, 2014
09:25Sambafoot Sunday: Ney Problem - Can Brazil Cope Without Neymar?
July 05, 2014
23:45Argentina forward Lionel Messi aiming for the World Cup final
23:30Medic insists vertebra injury will not compromise Neymar’s career
July 04, 2014
23:59Thiago Silva defends emotional Brazil
23:55James Rodriguez: David Luiz told me I was a good player
23:50David Luiz looks forward to "classic" encounter with Germany
23:47David Luiz: Colombia would have gone further if they “hadn't come up against Brazil”
15:34Luiz Felipe Scolari feels Brazil’s lack of a rivalry with Colombia will allow his players to be “more at ease'
July 03, 2014
18:58Brazil v Colombia – Preview
July 02, 2014
22:14Neymar confirms he is fit to face Colombia
22:10Colombia Head Coach Jose Pekerman confident his side can upset Brazil
22:06Neymar insists he can fit in any formation amid rumours that Luiz Felipe Scolari will switch to a 3-5-2 against Colombia
22:02Neymar happy for Brazil to win 1-0 against Colombia
July 01, 2014
23:24Fernandinho confident Brazil can handle expectations
June 30, 2014
16:29Brazil Head Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari unsure whether Neymar will be fit to face Colombia
16:24Brazil Head Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari compares Neymar to Cristiano Ronaldo
June 29, 2014
23:11Diego Maradona: "Chile deserved to go through"
23:00Colombia playmaker James Rodriguez respectful of Brazil
21:23Colombia playmaker James Rodriguez hopeful of Brazil victory
19:21Diego Maradona excited by Colombia and James Rodriguez
June 28, 2014
21:04Brazil vs. Chile: Player ratings
16:14Brazil vs Chile: Line up
June 26, 2014
14:33Report: Flamengo one of eight clubs who have enquired about loaning Internazionale midfielder Rubén Botta
June 16, 2014
11:35Brazil Head Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari backs Portugal to recovery from heavy Germany defeat
June 09, 2014
23:18Italy forward Lorenzo Insigne insists Italy’s poor defending in victory against Fluminense is “not important”
23:12Italy forward Ciro Immobile “excited” with hat-trick against Fluminense
22:56Italy Head Coach Cesare Prandelli pleased with Fluminense victory
22:52Italy Head Coach Cesare Prandelli delighted with Brazilian support
June 07, 2014
23:32Italy line up confirmed for Fluminense friendly
May 19, 2014
22:13Portugal Manager Paulo Bento names his 23-man 2014 FIFA World Cup squad
May 18, 2014
19:09Sambafoot Sunday: Botafogo's Shaky Start to 2014
April 13, 2014
08:34Sambafoot Sunday: Brazilian Clubs' Libertadores Numbers Game
April 06, 2014
09:20Sambafoot Sunday: Atlético Mineiro's Anelka Interest Should be the Norm
February 14, 2014
12:23Shakhtar Donetsk: President decided to support Maicon’s family
February 09, 2014
09:25Sambafoot Sunday: Where’s Wallyson? Botafogo find their new hero post-Seedorf
January 26, 2014
10:09Sambafoot Sunday: Cruciate curse affects Seleção hopes of three midfielders
December 01, 2013
13:36Sambafoot Sunday: Could Éverton Ribeiro Crack Europe?
November 25, 2013
11:39Brasileirão Week 36 round up: Vasco shock champions to stay in contention while defeat leaves Ponte Preta on the brink
November 24, 2013
10:17Sambafoot Sunday: Palmeiras Promoted with Chapecoense in Tow
November 17, 2013
12:00Palmeiras secure Brasileirão Série B title with 3-0 win against Boa Esporte
November 12, 2013
08:42Relegation threatened Fluminense sack head coach Vanderlei Luxemburgo
November 10, 2013
12:59Sambafoot Sunday: Atlético Paranaense's hurricane season
November 09, 2013
10:05Drummer angers Flamengo fans
November 04, 2013
13:04Brasileirão week 32 round-up: Big win for Vasco as in-form Goiás maintain top four push
November 03, 2013
17:31Sambafoot Sunday: Surprise Packages in the 2013 Brasileirão
October 28, 2013
11:31Brasileirão Week 31 round up: Vital win for Ponte Preta while Goiás maintain top four push
October 21, 2013
13:21Olympique Marseille without defender Lucas Mendes for Napoli fixture
12:12Injury rules Bayern Munich defender Dante out of Viktoria Plzeň tie
October 20, 2013
23:50São Paulo president Juvenal Juvêncio admits interest in Lucas Moura loan return
October 18, 2013
11:47Diego Maradona dispute’s Pelé’s FIFA recognition
09:04Del Bosque: Costa approach no insult to current strikers
October 17, 2013
21:43Hard work is paying off insists Bayern Munich defender Rafinha
13:17Rodrigo Lasmar: Ronaldinho on track to be fit for the Club World Cup
October 16, 2013
19:53Report: Tottenham Hotspur set to offer Paulinho extended deal
09:12Report: São Paulo could terminate Lúcio’s contract if injury concerns prevail
October 13, 2013
18:32Brasileirão: Grêmio slip up as Vitoria and Santos grab victories
14:49Vanderlei Luxemburgo: ‘Simulation part of football’
October 09, 2013
20:37Mineiro learn Club World Cup fate
October 06, 2013
22:39Oswaldo de Oliveira in hospital after Botafogo defeat
11:55Sambafoot Sunday: Cruzeiro cruising at the top of the Brasileirão
October 04, 2013
23:52Internacional manager Dunga sacked
September 14, 2013
14:29Guerrero: Corinthians can still be champions
September 11, 2013
20:49Roberto Carlos: Anzhi could collapse
14:57Exeter City play down Brazil fears
September 07, 2013
14:12Atlético Madrid's Filipe Luis: Barca-Madrid dominance an injustice
September 06, 2013
19:04Santos announce tour of South East Asia
18:42São Paulo slump to defeat as Rogerio Ceni misses penalty
September 05, 2013
19:17Cruzeiro go four points clear after defeating Bahia
18:43Romário and Maradona fight against CONMEBOL corruption
September 03, 2013
21:29Marcelo Mattos says Botafogo will overcome difficulties
20:54Réver believes Atlético Mineiro can challenge for Brazilian title
September 02, 2013
23:21São Paulo to honour Brazil legend Leonidas da Silva
July 23, 2014
21:19Flamengo reappoint Vanderlei Luxemburgo as Head Coach following Ney Franco sacking
19:42Santos Vice-President Odílio Rodrigues Filho admits Robinho deal will be "a difficult operation"
15:17Report: Werder Bremen set to sign Internacional defender Cláudio Winck
13:43President Enrique Cerezo believes Atlético de Madrid can cope with Diego Costa and Filipe Luís sales and refutes Miranda rumours
10:07Report: Roma in negotiations with São Paulo to re-sign defender Rafael Tolói
July 22, 2014
23:27Report: Cruzeiro set to hold talks with Milan over Robinho
23:16Former Internacional forward Ignacio Scocco set for Newell's Old Boys return
23:11Agent confirms Robinho offers amid interest from Cruzeiro and Orlando City
14:36Al-Wasl team manager Majed Obaidallah confirms loan signing of Fábio Lima from Atlético Goianiense
12:44Report: Juventus and Roma could move for Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa following refusal to return to Ukraine
July 21, 2014
23:53Report: Barcelona to target São Paulo defender Rodrigo Caio
23:47La Liga newcomers Córdoba confirm the loan signing of forward Ryder Matos from Fiorentina
23:42Serie B newcomers Perugia sign veteran midfielder Rodrigo Taddei on a free transfer from Roma
23:352014 Brasileirão Round 11 summary: Internacional thump struggling Flamengo
July 19, 2014
23:01Report: Hellas Verona to target Cagliari forward Nenê
09:30Report: Chelsea set to move for Atlético de Madrid defender Miranda after completing deal for Filipe Luís
July 18, 2014
22:42Udinese complete the signing of midfielder Guilherme from Corinthians
22:34Robinho representative suggests temporary switch to Brazil is likely
22:31Representative confirms negotiations between Milan and Orlando City over Robinho
22:27Report: Livorno striker Paulinho set to join Al Arabi
17:542014 Brasileirão Round 10 summary: Newly promoted Sport Recife shock Botafogo
10:51Report: Genoa set to sign defender Edenílson on loan from Udinese
July 17, 2014
22:58Report: Sunderland forward Ignacio Scocco can't return to Newell's Old Boys until payment is settled with Internacional
22:53Exeter City manager Paul Tisdale bemoans lack of a second goalkeeper for Fluminense test
22:49Exeter City Manager Paul Tisdale expecting stern test against Fluminense
22:42Santos Head Coach Oswaldo de Oliveira hopeful for Robinho return
22:37Former Croatia international Eduardo signs for Flamengo
22:33New Flamengo signing Eduardo retires from international football
July 16, 2014
23:07Daniel Alves defends new Barcelona teammate Luis Suarez
23:02Daniel Alves wants Barcelona stay
22:57Report: Robinho to Santos before joining Kaka at Orlando City
22:52Livorno forward Paulinho considering a number of offers
July 14, 2014
23:52Hellas Verona confirm signing of Romulo from Fiorentina
23:12Cafu expects former Chelsea defender Ashley Cole to succeed at Roma
23:12Maicon wants a new deal at Roma
July 12, 2014
23:39Dodo hails Walter Mazzarri influence in Internazionale move
July 11, 2014
23:01Milan Vice President Adriano Galliani hails capture of Brazilian defender Alex
22:58Internazionale defender Juan Jesus talks Nemanja Vidic and Alexandre Pato
22:54Internazionale defender Juan Jesus thankful for fans support after long injury layoff
22:46Rodrigo Taddei open to Fiorentina switch
July 09, 2014
23:59Goalkeeper Diego Alves signs a new five year deal with Valencia
23:36Dodo thanks Roma fans after agreeing Internazionale move
July 07, 2014
22:16Report: Roma defender Dodo set to join Internazionale on loan
22:11Report: Alexandre Pato's wage demands are holding up potential Internazionale move
22:01Maicon confident he will win the Scudetto with Roma
July 02, 2014
22:21Kaka expects Robinho to join him in Major League Soccer
July 01, 2014
23:14Ethics committee confirms claims of match fixing against Cameroon will be investigated
23:13Angel Di Maria believes Argentina deserved to beat Switzerland
23:12Chelsea confirm signing of Atlético Madrid forward Diego Costa
June 30, 2014
16:40Agent Tadeu Cruz denies that Kaka has left Milan for family reasons
Paris Saint-Germain    Onze Mondial Football Ukraine    Sport Consulting    
To the top