Some thoughts on Tom Finney, and on how Bangu lost out to the force of Flamengo

The legacy of the late Tom Finney is not mirrored in Brazil - Action Images
Last Saturday I gave a lecture in Rio where I was honoured with the presence of Juninho Pernambucano in my small audience.

I prepared my material the day before, and in an aside about the historical depth of English football, I sought to make a few points by using the example of Tom Finney.  Poignancy was added when the news came through that Finney had died at the age of 91 – certainly one of the candidates for the title of England’s best ever footballer.

 

I knew, though, that even a student of the game as diligent as Juninho would not have heard of Finney.  Although the great man had played in Brazil in the 1950 World Cup, it was not a moment on which Finney could look back with much pride.  And why should a Brazilian born in 1975 have heard of a player from previous decades who spent his entire career with Preston North End?

This neatly brings us to a point I was trying to make in my lecture.  If English football is currently so successful, and is held up all around the world as a reference, then part of that is explained by a simple equation.  The new money entering the game has proved so effective because the old culture is so strong.  And some of this can be explained by the example of Finney.

He played at a time when top footballers in England were deplorably treated.  With no freedom of contract, they were bound to their club for as long as the latter desired.  And the maximum wage was still in operation, meaning that even an artist like Finney, capable of filling stadiums up and down the country, could earn little more than a skilled factory worker.

Palermo came in with an offer that would have made Finney a wealthy man.  He was not even told about it.  Preston were not selling, and that was that!  And there would have been little point, in financial terms, in making the short move to Manchester United.  With the maximum wage restriction, he would not be able to earn at Old Trafford any more than he was getting at Preston.  And so, during the close season, he continued to work as a plummer.  And he played all of his club football for a team from a town so small that the entire population could fit into the old pre-modernisation Maracana stadium.

This is clearly absurd.  Yet it is also undeniable that something positive came from these grossly unfair restrictions on the players’ mobility and earnings potential.  By such measures, the process of concentration – where all the top players drift towards the biggest clubs – was retarded.  Not every club could boast a Tom Finney, but all of them, at some time, had players of great talent around whom the club could build a tradition and an identity.  All of this filters through to the current day, when clubs from all over England, with far more tradition than hopes of contemporary success, continue to draw crowds that are the envy of the Brazilian game.

Juninho acknowledged the point.  The division typically made in Brazil between big clubs (with mass support) and small ones (with next to no fans) was not one that could be easily applied to European football, especially in England.

Like much of the rest of South America, Brazilian football has had to fight against a centralisation which its roots in economic history.  Being an exporter of raw materials created strong ports and a weak hinterland – and thus most of the continent’s big teams are clustered in those bustling ports or nearby trade centres.

But even inside some of those big cities, the process of football centralisation is striking.  Take the example of Bangu, from Rio’s working class North Zone.  They have a long and proud tradition.  Some great players have worn their red and white stripes, such as legendary centre back Domingos da Guia and Zizinho, the idol of the young Pele.  They have a huge catchment area, and yet, no longer a national force, they survive on tiny gates towards the wrong end of the table in the Rio State Championship.  One of the Carnaval samba schools with the biggest following is Mocidade from the neighbouring district of Padre Miguel.  If Mocidade can agglomerate a mass support from Rio’s North Zone, then surely Bangu should be able to do something similar.  Put a club with the tradition of Bangu in the context of London or Buenos Aires and they would be huge.  But not in Brazil.  Why?

Radio has something to do with it.  Football in England pre-dates the electronic media, giving the sport a chance to grow locally and organically.  In Brazil, radio did much to spread the game – and as radio came into the peak of its power in the late 30s and 1940s, there was one club with whom it was very hard for the likes of Bangu to compete – Flamengo.

Between 1933 and 38 Flamengo had a visionary for a president.  Jose Bastos Padilha saw and understood the changes that were taking place in Brazilian football and society.  Professionalism came in, rocking the game’s amateur ethos.  Meanwhile, the relatively benign tropical fascism of Getulio Vargas sought to set up a cross-class alliance, forming a country where for the first time the black Brazilian was included in the national identity.

Flamengo responded by signing the leading black players of the day, including the son of Bangu, Domingos da Guia.  Even more important was charismatic, controversial and magnificently talented centre forward Leonidas da Silva.  At a stroke Flamengo rebranded themselves; they had been a club of the South Zone elite.  Now, dramatically, they had acquired the popular touch.  The clubs from the working class suburbs could not compete.

After a decade with Flamengo, the great Zizinho played some of his most mature football in a seven year spell in the red and white of Bangu.  He is a contemporary of Tom Finney, and there are similarities in their styles.  But even if Bangu had possessed an entire team of Finneys and Zizinhos it is hard to see how they could have avoided having their support base eaten up by Flamengo.  The local fan did not just want to associate himself with his own neighbourhood.  When he opted for Flamengo it was as if he was buying a stake in the new Brazil, the land of the future.

 

Latest articles

Robinho: 'I want to stay at Santos'

Fabinho confident ahead of the season run in with Monaco

Report: Arsenal, Liverpool and Manchester United to compete for TSG 1899 Hoffenheim attacking midfielder Roberto Firmino

Report: Avellino's Rodrigo Ely and Livorno full-back Maicon turn down Italy to represent Brazil

Hoffenheim forward Roberto Firmino hails Brazil Head Coach Dunga

Liverpool's Lucas thrilled to meet Pele

Liverpool eye a shock swoop for Chelsea's Oscar

Alan Shearer tip's Chelsea's Costa for the golden boot

Filipe Luís: 'I plan to stay at Chelsea'

Leonardo concedes it “will be difficult” for him to return to Paris Saint-Germain

Report: Expected Brazil line up for Chile friendly

Chile Head Coach Jorge Sampaoli concedes he will have to rotate for Brazil friendly

Lucas-Liverpool: "Philippe Coutinho could be anything he wants to be"

Sampdoria forward Eder pleased to silence critics with debut Italy goal

Dunga hails Chelsa's Willian as key player for Brazil

Dunga: "Players recuperate after 72 hours"

Dunga: "No more new players for the Copa America"

Miranda begins to form partnership with Thiago Silva

Marquinhos signs new PSG contract

Brazil U17 beat Paraguay

Diego Costa: 'Christmas fixture list took its toll'

Rafael faces a fight to get back into the Manchester United line up

Stefano Fiore: 'Anderson is better than Coutinho'

Chelsea's Diego Costa criticises English defenders

Lucas Leiva steps up his recovery from injury

Report: Arsenal and Chelsea to battle over Internacional midfielder Charles Aranguiz

Shakhtar Donetsk forward Luiz Adriano hints at December exit

Sampdoria forward Eder believes controversy over Italy call up is "nonsense"

Leonardo: 'Not enough Brazilian managers in Europe'

Philippe Coutinho: 'Liverpool can make the top four'

Latest News.

  • All
  • Seleção
  • Teams
  • Players
March 31, 2015
13:00Dunga reveals the huge pressure in managing Seleção
13:00Neymar angered by rough treatment from Chile
13:00Lucas Silva open to loan move from Real Madrid
13:00Dunga praises attacking contribution of Chelsea's Willian
13:00Neymar closing in on Pelé
12:56Andreas Pereira and Manchester United set for crunch talks
12:47Robinho: 'I want to stay at Santos'
12:32Fabinho confident ahead of the season run in with Monaco
08:02Report: Arsenal, Liverpool and Manchester United to compete for TSG 1899 Hoffenheim attacking midfielder Roberto Firmino
07:22Report: Avellino's Rodrigo Ely and Livorno full-back Maicon turn down Italy to represent Brazil
March 30, 2015
15:50Hoffenheim forward Roberto Firmino hails Brazil Head Coach Dunga
13:16Liverpool's Glen Johnson can replace Dani Alves at Barcelona
13:14Brazil players are determined to make amends, says Dunga
13:12Third-party sent written demand to all parties and persons involved in Neymar deal
13:10Dani Alves: 'My heart is happy in Barcelona'
13:07Dunga: 'Neymar will be judged on World Cup wins'
12:37Liverpool's Lucas thrilled to meet Pele
12:22Liverpool eye a shock swoop for Chelsea's Oscar
12:11Alan Shearer tip's Chelsea's Costa for the golden boot
12:04Filipe Luís: 'I plan to stay at Chelsea'
March 29, 2015
17:55Leonardo concedes it “will be difficult” for him to return to Paris Saint-Germain
17:53Roberto Firmino's strike ensures victory for a poor Brazil against Chile
15:32Brazil x Chile: Live
14:30Chelsea's Filipe Luis: "Alexis Sanchez is really dangerous"
14:07Report: Expected Brazil line up for Chile friendly
13:59Chile Head Coach Jorge Sampaoli concedes he will have to rotate for Brazil friendly
13:17Lucas-Liverpool: "Philippe Coutinho could be anything he wants to be"
12:47Sampdoria forward Eder pleased to silence critics with debut Italy goal
March 28, 2015
20:30Arsenal centre-back Gabriel Paulista: "I want to defend and defend well"
19:57Dunga hails Chelsa's Willian as key player for Brazil
19:50Dunga: "Neymar to overhaul Pele's Brazil goal record"
19:45Dunga: "Players recuperate after 72 hours"
19:42Dunga: "No more new players for the Copa America"
19:32Lucas-Liverpool: "It will be just like old times again"
18:25Top European club chasing Chelsea Midfielder Oscar
17:15Chelsea star Ramires facing summer Stamford Bridge exit
13:25Barcelona president: 'We signed Neymar to be our Beckham'
13:20Liverpool's Philippe Coutinho says he must score more goals to be considered as one of the best midfielders in Europe
13:16Arsenal's Alexis Sánchez excited for Chile's special rematch against Brazil
13:14Dunga thinks Brazil have rediscovered their self-belief
13:12Barça president Bartomeu to Judge Ruz: 'Tito Vilanova asked us to sign Neymar a year earlier'
March 27, 2015
13:29Manchester United and Liverpool still battling for Dani Alves
13:27Pelé: 'Impossible for Neymar to replace me'
13:25Dunga says confidence and balance key to Brazil's winning run
13:22Dani Alves releases charity single with former Barcelona keeper José Pinto
13:20Victory over France not a revenge, says Neymar
11:04Miranda begins to form partnership with Thiago Silva
10:57Marquinhos signs new PSG contract
10:45Brazil U17 beat Paraguay
March 26, 2015
22:59Ruthless Brazil defeat France 3-1 in Paris
March 31, 2015
13:00Neymar closing in on Pelé
13:00Dunga praises attacking contribution of Chelsea's Willian
13:00Lucas Silva open to loan move from Real Madrid
13:00Neymar angered by rough treatment from Chile
13:00Dunga reveals the huge pressure in managing Seleção
March 30, 2015
13:16Liverpool's Glen Johnson can replace Dani Alves at Barcelona
13:14Brazil players are determined to make amends, says Dunga
13:12Third-party sent written demand to all parties and persons involved in Neymar deal
13:10Dani Alves: 'My heart is happy in Barcelona'
13:07Dunga: 'Neymar will be judged on World Cup wins'
March 28, 2015
13:25Barcelona president: 'We signed Neymar to be our Beckham'
13:20Liverpool's Philippe Coutinho says he must score more goals to be considered as one of the best midfielders in Europe
13:16Arsenal's Alexis Sánchez excited for Chile's special rematch against Brazil
13:14Dunga thinks Brazil have rediscovered their self-belief
13:12Barça president Bartomeu to Judge Ruz: 'Tito Vilanova asked us to sign Neymar a year earlier'
March 27, 2015
13:29Manchester United and Liverpool still battling for Dani Alves
13:27Pelé: 'Impossible for Neymar to replace me'
13:25Dunga says confidence and balance key to Brazil's winning run
13:22Dani Alves releases charity single with former Barcelona keeper José Pinto
13:20Victory over France not a revenge, says Neymar
March 26, 2015
13:35Dunga says 1998 World Cup final defeat to France still hurts
13:34Neymar won't convince Manchester United target Danilo to sign for Barcelona
13:32Philippe Coutinho says Liverpool have a good chance of securing a top-four
13:30Dunga says sky is the limit for Neymar
13:28Neymar's father defends Barcelona deal
March 25, 2015
13:00Kaká's dream XI revealed; Messi not included
13:00Roberto Firmino set to start for Brazil against France
13:00Danilo proud of Real Madrid interest
13:00Neymar - The most expensive player in history?
13:00Kaká thinks he was better than Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo
March 24, 2015
13:00Neymar looks forward to the friendly against France
13:00Bayern will not sell Dante, insists Sammer
13:00Luis Suárez: 'Neymar is right to be selfish'
13:00Marcelo says Real Madrid will never surrender
13:00Neymar case - Public prosecutor requests prison sentence for Sandro Rosell and Bartomeu
March 23, 2015
13:00Liverpool landlord: 'I beat Pele - and bit him too!'
13:00Liverpool target Felipe Anderson's contract renewed by Lazio
13:00Dani Alves assists winning goal in El Clásico
13:00Messi is better than Cristiano, says Pelé
13:00Felipe Anderson: 'Lazio are improving every game'
March 21, 2015
13:00Arsenal want Charles Aránguiz from Internacional
13:00Messi, Suárez and Neymar have scored 55 league goals this season
13:00Former West Brom striker faces ban after crossing Dani Alves' ex-wife
13:00Arsenal goalkeeper Ospina reveals frustration over Colombia's World Cup loss to Brazil
13:00São Paulo trying to take Nathan from Atlético Paranaense
March 20, 2015
13:00Zé Roberto talks about his Copa América memories and how he maintains fitness at the age of 40
13:00Liverpool to miss out on Felipe Anderson
13:00Maxwell extends PSG contract
13:00Hart: 'I just tried to smother Messi, Neymar & Suárez'
13:00Dani Alves set to snub Manchester United move as he eyes Barcelona stay
January 19, 2015
20:37Willian: 'Chelsea controlled the game'
January 11, 2015
19:49Coritiba confirm the signings of Negueba and Pedro Ken
17:17De Arrascaeta to Internacional can be announced any time now, says Defensor president
January 04, 2015
16:03Mircea Lucescu: Tour of Brazil will become part of Shakhtar history
15:08Lucescu: Shakhtar’s Brazil tour will be part of the history
January 03, 2015
12:16Sergei Palkin: It’s important for us to play with the top teams of the Brazilian league
January 02, 2015
16:49Cruzeiro confirm survey from Mexico regarding Anselmo Ramon
15:28Internacional have competition from Europe for De Arrascaeta
14:16No contacts with Internacional, says Sandro's agent
14:13Shakhtar goes on tour across Brazil
December 30, 2014
17:18Fluminense director says no offer for Darío Conca
December 25, 2014
14:37Leandro Damião to Cruzeiro is back on
June 26, 2014
14:33Report: Flamengo one of eight clubs who have enquired about loaning Internazionale midfielder Rubén Botta
June 16, 2014
11:35Brazil Head Coach Luiz Felipe Scolari backs Portugal to recovery from heavy Germany defeat
June 09, 2014
23:18Italy forward Lorenzo Insigne insists Italy’s poor defending in victory against Fluminense is “not important”
23:12Italy forward Ciro Immobile “excited” with hat-trick against Fluminense
22:56Italy Head Coach Cesare Prandelli pleased with Fluminense victory
22:52Italy Head Coach Cesare Prandelli delighted with Brazilian support
June 07, 2014
23:32Italy line up confirmed for Fluminense friendly
May 19, 2014
22:13Portugal Manager Paulo Bento names his 23-man 2014 FIFA World Cup squad
May 18, 2014
19:09Sambafoot Sunday: Botafogo's Shaky Start to 2014
April 13, 2014
08:34Sambafoot Sunday: Brazilian Clubs' Libertadores Numbers Game
April 06, 2014
09:20Sambafoot Sunday: Atlético Mineiro's Anelka Interest Should be the Norm
February 14, 2014
12:23Shakhtar Donetsk: President decided to support Maicon’s family
February 09, 2014
09:25Sambafoot Sunday: Where’s Wallyson? Botafogo find their new hero post-Seedorf
January 26, 2014
10:09Sambafoot Sunday: Cruciate curse affects Seleção hopes of three midfielders
December 01, 2013
13:36Sambafoot Sunday: Could Éverton Ribeiro Crack Europe?
November 25, 2013
11:39Brasileirão Week 36 round up: Vasco shock champions to stay in contention while defeat leaves Ponte Preta on the brink
November 24, 2013
10:17Sambafoot Sunday: Palmeiras Promoted with Chapecoense in Tow
November 17, 2013
12:00Palmeiras secure Brasileirão Série B title with 3-0 win against Boa Esporte
November 12, 2013
08:42Relegation threatened Fluminense sack head coach Vanderlei Luxemburgo
November 10, 2013
12:59Sambafoot Sunday: Atlético Paranaense's hurricane season
November 09, 2013
10:05Drummer angers Flamengo fans
November 04, 2013
13:04Brasileirão week 32 round-up: Big win for Vasco as in-form Goiás maintain top four push
November 03, 2013
17:31Sambafoot Sunday: Surprise Packages in the 2013 Brasileirão
October 28, 2013
11:31Brasileirão Week 31 round up: Vital win for Ponte Preta while Goiás maintain top four push
October 21, 2013
13:21Olympique Marseille without defender Lucas Mendes for Napoli fixture
12:12Injury rules Bayern Munich defender Dante out of Viktoria Plzeň tie
October 20, 2013
23:50São Paulo president Juvenal Juvêncio admits interest in Lucas Moura loan return
October 18, 2013
11:47Diego Maradona dispute’s Pelé’s FIFA recognition
09:04Del Bosque: Costa approach no insult to current strikers
October 17, 2013
21:43Hard work is paying off insists Bayern Munich defender Rafinha
13:17Rodrigo Lasmar: Ronaldinho on track to be fit for the Club World Cup
October 16, 2013
19:53Report: Tottenham Hotspur set to offer Paulinho extended deal
09:12Report: São Paulo could terminate Lúcio’s contract if injury concerns prevail
October 13, 2013
18:32Brasileirão: Grêmio slip up as Vitoria and Santos grab victories
14:49Vanderlei Luxemburgo: ‘Simulation part of football’
October 09, 2013
20:37Mineiro learn Club World Cup fate
October 06, 2013
22:39Oswaldo de Oliveira in hospital after Botafogo defeat
11:55Sambafoot Sunday: Cruzeiro cruising at the top of the Brasileirão
March 31, 2015
08:02Report: Arsenal, Liverpool and Manchester United to compete for TSG 1899 Hoffenheim attacking midfielder Roberto Firmino
07:22Report: Avellino's Rodrigo Ely and Livorno full-back Maicon turn down Italy to represent Brazil
March 30, 2015
15:50Hoffenheim forward Roberto Firmino hails Brazil Head Coach Dunga
March 29, 2015
17:55Leonardo concedes it “will be difficult” for him to return to Paris Saint-Germain
14:07Report: Expected Brazil line up for Chile friendly
13:59Chile Head Coach Jorge Sampaoli concedes he will have to rotate for Brazil friendly
12:47Sampdoria forward Eder pleased to silence critics with debut Italy goal
March 28, 2015
18:25Top European club chasing Chelsea Midfielder Oscar
17:15Chelsea star Ramires facing summer Stamford Bridge exit
March 25, 2015
17:17Report: Arsenal and Chelsea to battle over Internacional midfielder Charles Aranguiz
16:29Shakhtar Donetsk forward Luiz Adriano hints at December exit
15:56Sampdoria forward Eder believes controversy over Italy call up is "nonsense"
March 23, 2015
17:00FIGC President Carlo Tavecchio defends decision to select Sampdoria forward Eder for Italy
17:00Agent unhappy with controversy surrounding Sampdoria forward Eder's selection for Italy
March 22, 2015
15:28Corinthians Head Coach Tite hails defender Gil following Brazil call up
13:32Philippe Coutinho insists Liverpool "will do everything to come out victorious" against Manchester United
12:54Agent Andrea Bagnoli admits Italy call up is a "dream come true" for Sampdoria forward Éder
March 19, 2015
17:15Chelsea use former player Deco to sign Fluminense's star
March 18, 2015
14:05Report: Internazionale step up pursuit of Corinthians forward Paolo Guerrero
13:58Almeria loanee Wellington Silva confident of making an impression at Arsenal next season
13:54Report: Midfielder Wellington Silva in talks with Arsenal over new contract
March 17, 2015
21:48Manchester United have become latest English club to watch Roberto Firmino
20:45Twente almost signed Chelsea's Diego Costa
17:42Palmeiras Head Coach Oswaldo de Oliveira explains why midfielder Jorge Valdivia will not link up with Chile
17:37Lazio midfielder Felipe Anderson hopes for Brazil call up and closes in on new contract
17:28Lazio midfielder Felipe Anderson believes in Champions League qualification
March 16, 2015
12:33Intermediary Eduardo Valdes confirms Chelsea and Juventus interest in Fluminense forward Kenedy
12:23Intermediary Eduardo Valdes suggests São Paulo loanee Alexandre Pato will eventually move to England or Italy
March 15, 2015
21:10Report: Chelsea agree €25.3 million deal for Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa
21:05Report: Sampdoria forward Eder to be called up by Italy Head Coach Antonio Conte
March 13, 2015
17:08Report: Proposal made to add play-offs to Brasileirão campaign has presidential support
15:56Manchester City midfielder Fernandinho insists he missed Leicester City game due to injury and looks to Burnley
15:05Defender Felipe admits Internazionale move happened quickly
14:04Manchester City midfielder Fernandinho explains alleged altercation with captain Vincent Kompany
13:12Marcelo Fernandes named as new Santos Head Coach
March 11, 2015
16:52Report: Barcelona consider Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Douglas Costa as possible replacement for Pedro
15:38Corinthians Head Coach Tite believes goalkeeper Cássio Ramos deserves Brazil call up
14:43São Paulo loanee Alexandre Pato disappointed to be barred from playing against owners Corinthians
14:04Forward Luiz Adriano does not expect Shakhtar Donetsk to be intimidated when they face Bayern Munich at Allianz Arena
13:05Atlético de Madrid midfielder Cristian Rodríguez arrives in Brazil after agreeing to join Grêmio on loan
March 10, 2015
19:07Paris Saint-Germain manager Laurent Blanc wary of "provocative" Chelsea forward Diego Costa
17:42Report: Manchester United submit bid for Fluminense forward Kenedy
17:34Report: Roma defender Maicon could return for Europa League tie against Fiorentina
15:05EXCLUSIVE-Wellington Silva: "I am ready now to play for Arsenal"
March 08, 2015
21:24Report: Manchester United continue to push for Fluminense starlet Kenedy
21:16Santos loanee Robinho delighted to earn Brazil recall
21:11Parma loanee Cristian Rodriguez suggests he is set to move on to Gremio.
March 05, 2015
17:52Report: Liverpool to target Atalanta goalkeeper Marco Sportiello rather than Fiorentina's Neto
16:55Gilberto Silva hopes Arsenal can keep winning despite lack of big spending
16:15Former Arsenal midfielder Gilberto Silva insists Mesut Özil must improve
To the top